WEDNESDAY, 21 FEB 2018

 

CONNECT

Facebook Linked In Twitter
PwC_02/02_23/02_728x90px
GloriaJeans_266x90px
IMH LTD

Syllouris: Cyprus Solution Exclusively Depends On Turkey Stance

Kouyialis: Cyprus Expects EU to Maintain Improved Direct Payments System In Future CAP

IMH LTD
PwC_02/02_23/02_468x60px

OPINION

Swiss Franc Mortgages

Swiss Franc Mortgages

Swiss Franc loan contracts involved thousands of borrowers in default, both in Cyprus and other Balkan and European countries. This particular banking product, promoted especially in the early 2000's, resulted in a severe socio-economic problem due to the depreciation of the exchange rates. The indignation of borrowers, who observed a substantial increase in their balances on their loans and payments, forced them to resort to legal measures to defend their legal rights and entitlements.

The start of the judicial processes in various other European Courts and their decisions in favour of the borrowers have played a prominent role in the protection of creditors’ legal rights and the treatment of lending contracts that contained controversial and damaging clauses. Consequently, national European courts have tended to adopt decisions in favour of the borrowers.

Recently, in Cyprus, the first partial vindication of a borrower was heard before the District Court of Nicosia in a case that contested the banks overcharges and the financial loss caused by the depreciation of the exchange rate between the Swiss Franc and the euro. The loan had been granted by the bank for the purpose of funding emergency housing.

The Plaintiffs (borrowers), as with the majority of bona fide borrowers, paid their loan instalments meticulously and regularly. However, their loan never reduced over time and, in fact, continued to increase.

Swiss Franc borrowers were forced to convert their funds to pay their loan instalments on the day that the payments were due and according to the exchange rate on the date of the instalment payment. The devaluation and considerable downturn of the Swiss Franc negatively affected the loans and compounded the interest on them.

The plaintiffs in this particular case requested the issuance of a protective interim order under the provision of Article 32 of law 14/60 for (a) the suspension of the monthly instalments on the agreement and (b) suspension of the defendants’ life insurances with two insurance companies in favour of the borrowers and not the bank.

The Cypriot Court, correctly interpreting the European Directive 93/13/EEC on the unfair terms in loan contracts, applied the European Precedent of the European decision C-26/13 Kasler and Rabai v OPT Jelzalogbank Zrt dated 30/04/2014 regarding the borrowing of Swiss Francs and questioned the clauses that weakened the other parties’ negotiation chances and, in particular, the bank’s position of "take it or leave it" that was in violation of the borrowers’ principles of autonomy and their contractual freedoms.

It is on this basis that the Cypriot Court, referred to the decision of the European Court of Justice in the case of Kasler for the understandable wording of terms so that they are meaningful and clear to a borrower.

It is widely viewed that the judge's final verdict will primarily centre on 'whether the manner and kind of lending represents a common loan agreement, for which the borrower knows from the beginning that he will be required to pay back a specific amount including the relevant interest on the loan'.

The Court rightly determined in the case that the borrower was not in a contractual position to have knowledge of the entire sum of the loan and the obligations/relationship between the lender and borrower. In these types of loan contracts, the content is normally unknown and/or undefined and/or unclear in the repayment of loans that are reliant on exchange rate fluctuations (between the currency of the loan contract and the currency of the borrower's income), including the variable interest rates imposed on the loan.

Although, the Cyprus Government has, to date, not taken a stance on this matter, the Cypriot justice system has followed both European and Case Law in protecting borrowers from contracts containing unfair and concealed terms by the banks for the sole purpose of gaining a profit.

The first Cypriot judgment (albeit interim) regarding Swiss franc loans, in conjunction with the European Legislation and Law, is a formidable safeguard available to borrowers in difficulty who wish to restore through the Courts the financial losses that they have suffered.

MORE ON OPINION

Let’s Focus on our Neighbourhood!

In November, the President of the Institute and I had the privilege of participating in ...

VAT on the Purchase of Cyprus Land

A new bill imposing Value Added Tax (VAT) on the supply of building land has been ...

Taxation of Deemed Benefits on Loans and Advances to Directors and Shareholders

Interpretative Circular 14, issued by the Tax Department on November 14 2017, clarifies ...

FROM AROUND GOLDNEWS

   

Ikea Joins Big Clean Switch to Offer 100% Renewable Energy Tariff

Joint venture claims cheaper green power could save UK households £300 a year Ikea is calling for households to join its latest joint venture ...
   

Cyprus Records Deflation Of 1.5% in January

Cyprus recorded deflation of 1.5% on an annual basis in January, official data released on Monday 20 February show.   The Harmonized Price Index for ...
   

Kouyialis: Cyprus Expects EU to Maintain Improved Direct Payments System In Future CAP

Cyprus expects the EU to maintain the role of direct payments as a means of supplementing and supporting agricultural incomes during the revision of the EU ...
   

HSBC Profits Jump to $17.2bn on Asia Growth

HSBC has posted a pre-tax profit of $17.2bn (£12.3bn) in 2017, saying its focus on Asia was driving growth. The results represent a 141% jump on the ...
   

KFC in UK Closing 900 Outlets

KFC has closed more than half of its 900 UK outlets after delivery problems meant they ran out of chicken. Last week, the fried chicken chain switched its ...
   

Significant Distinctions for Louis Hotels on Tripadvisor

2018 began very positively for Louis Hotels as it achieved high scores for 20 distinctions through the popular travelling website Tripadvisor. In fact, three ...
   

TUS Officially Launches Its Direct Flights to Ioannina

The Cyprus-based TUS Airways: "The Ultimate Schedule" officially launched, on Friday the 16th of February, its new route from Larnaca to Ioannina. ...
   

Production in Construction up By 0.1% In Euro Area For December 2017

Seasonally adjusted production in the construction sector in December 2017 compared with November 2017, increased by 0.1% in the euro area (EA19) and by 0.6% ...
 

YOUR COMMENTS

HEADLINES

MOST POPULAR

Deloitte_2016_300x250px
Gold_Digital_Edition_300x250px

IMH LTD